I’ve been getting questions about The Coach lately; people are wondering if I’ve heard anything about how repairs are progressing and when it might reopen. Last week I finally had a chance to stop down there and chat with owner Fritz Sierk, who filled me in on how things are going.
It’s been almost eight months since the devastating St. Patrick’s Day fire that tore through The Coach. It started behind the bar, and while the building remained structurally sound, the heat, smoke and water damage meant that the whole place had to be gutted. It’s been a long process cleaning it out, removing the destroyed equipment and furnishings, and drawing up the new plans, and there were several hurdles along the way, but construction finally began in earnest about three weeks ago.
The interior of the bar is still pretty much stripped down to the beams and studs, which was kind of sad to see. And you can still see a lot of fire damage (including charred beams from the last time it burned, in 1969). But Fritz’s vision of what “The Coach 2.0” (as he called it) will be like brought it back to life for me.
For starters, the bar area will be two feet bigger to accommodate larger sinks. The bathrooms “are going to be huge,” Fritz said, expanding into the former “smoking hut” space. A new overhang on the back deck will accommodate smokers, keeping them mostly out of the weather. A second, smaller, fenced-in patio will be added on the east end of the building. And perhaps most exciting of all, Fritz will be installing two garage-door windows overlooking the patios — similar to the big window at the Mary Wee Pub across the street. The pool table and darts will be back, and all of the TVs, including the four big ones on the west wall which can be used individually or stitched together as a huge screen.
In the end it’s still going to be the same, familiar Coach that we all know and love. Just a little bit better.
“I still want The Coach to be The Coach,” Fritz said. “Even though it’s new, we tried to make it comfortable, we tried to make it not too fancy. There are plenty of fancy places around.”
“You know. It’s the Coach.”
If construction stays on schedule, Fritz hopes to be open by late January. If not then, then definitely by the first weekend of February — in time to watch the Bills in the Super Bowl.
And all that work you’re seeing being done to the sidewalk in the front of the building? Don’t worry, most of it was planned, in part due to the new patio and garage-door windows. So even though it kind of looks like a mini disaster, rest assured it’s all part of the big plan and we’ll have our beloved Coach back before you know it.
* * *
email me at missyblog@gmail.com. “Like” this blog on Facebook and follow me on Instagram and Threads (@missyblog)
You can also get email notifications every time I post a new blog by using the “Subscribe” link on the right side of this page (or all the way at the bottom of the page if you’re on your phone).
(posted 11/2/2025)
webster on the web 
Please tell the owner of the coach to keep one charred beam cut to size from each fire to make a sign over the new threshold doorway (touch it before you enter; a transitional step old to new) or use some part of the beams to incorporate the main sign outside for those customers who have a history going there. It would give the Coach a remembrance of those who used to be around for their last round; a historical piece from years ago and lessen all the new inside. Thank you.
What a fantastic idea! Fritz might see this, but you should also post the comment to the Facebook post to make it even more likely. Thank you for writing.